When investing and purchasing dumbbells for your home gym or commercial fitness facility, you want to be sure that you're selecting the best option in terms of long term value, durability, grip, and material quality. Troy Barbell & Fitness and York Barbell are the two most well known brands in the business.
But, We got you! Which dumbell brand is better? Should you go for York's cast iron and rubber-coated dumbells that provides better value for your fitness goals, or go for Troy's premium urethane and rubber dumbbells?
To assist you in making a great choice, let's break down their features, pricing, durability, and best-use cases to help you make the right decision.
1. Troy Dumbbells: A Premium Choice for Durability & Performance
Troy Barbell & Fitness is known for producing high-quality commercial-grade dumbbells built for long-lasting durability and comfort. Their dumbbells are designed for both home gyms and professional training facilities, making them a top choice for personal trainers, gym owners, and fitness enthusiasts.
Troy Dumbbells – Product Range and Materials
Troy offers a variety of dumbbell types, including:
-
Troy Rubber Hex Dumbbells – These dumbbells include rubber-encased heads and solid steel handles to minimize noise and protect floors.
-
Troy Urethane Dumbbells – Premium urethane coating to ensures maximum durability and resistance to cracking or peeling.
-
Troy Pro-Style Dumbbells – Built with steel handles and machine weight plates, allowing customizable weight options.
👉 Explore Troy Dumbbells Here
Troy Dumbbells – Durability & Grip
✅ High-Quality Coatings – Urethane and rubber coatings prevent cracking, chipping, and fading over time.
✅ Ergonomic Handles – Knurled, contoured steel handles offer maximum grip and comfort, preventing slippage.
✅ Studio-Quality Design – Popular in commercial gyms, fitness studios, and group workout classes.
Who Should Buy Troy Dumbbells?
🏋️ Ideal for commercial gyms, dedicated lifters, and long-term durability seekers.
🏡 Perfect for home gym owners looking for durable, high-end dumbbells.
2. York Dumbbells: Affordable and Reliable for All Fitness Levels
York Barbell is one of the oldest fitness equipment manufacturers and is well known for its vinyl, rubber-coated, and cast iron dumbbells. They cater to both beginners and experienced lifters with a variety options.
York Dumbbells – Product Range and Materials
-
York Cast Iron Dumbbells – Are made of solid iron construction, have a classic design, and are meant to last a lifetime.
-
York Rubber Hex Dumbbells – Similar to Troy's Hex Dumbells but with rubber-encased heads for safety.
-
York Vinyl Fitbells – Are made for low-impact exercises including aerobics and rehab exercises..
👉 Check Out York Dumbbells Here
York Dumbbells – Durability & Grip
✅ Cast Iron Strength – Traditional cast iron dumbbells are built to last for decades.
✅ Textured Grip Handles – While some models have smooth handles, while others feature a slight texture for better grip.
✅ General Gym Use – Commonly used in commercial gyms and home setups.
Who Should Buy York Dumbbells?
🏋️ Best for home gym users, tight budget buyers, and general strength training.
💰 Great for those looking for a cost-effective option without compromising on quality.
3. Side-by-Side Comparison: Troy Dumbbells vs. York Dumbbells
| Feature |
Troy Dumbbells |
York Dumbbells |
| Material |
Urethane, rubber, cast iron |
Cast iron, rubber, vinyl |
| Durability |
✅ Lasts decades, no cracking |
✅ Cast iron lasts long but rubber may wear |
| Grip Comfort |
✅ Knurled, ergonomic grip |
✅ Straight handles, some with slight texture |
| Studio-Friendly? |
✅ Yes, protects floors |
❌ Can leave black marks on flooring |
| Best For |
✅ Strength training, HIIT, gyms |
✅ Home gyms, casual lifters, affordability |
4. Price vs. Long-Term Value
💰 Troy Dumbbells – Higher Cost, Lasts Longer
💰 York Dumbbells – More Affordable, May Wear Faster
-
Budget-friendly pricing for beginners or casual lifters.
- Cast iron dumbbells last long, but rubber-coated models may wear down faster
- Excellent for home gym users who want a balance of price and quality.
🛒 Best-Selling Troy Dumbbells
🛒 Best York Dumbbell Options
5. Maintenance & Care: How to Make Your Dumbbells Last
✅ Clean the dumbbells after each workout to remove sweat and dirt.
✅ For cast iron models, store it in a dry place to prevent rust.
✅ To prolong the lift of rubber or urethane dumbbells, you should avoid dropping them.
✅ Use a proper rack to keep dumbbells organized and protected.
🛒 Best Dumbbell Storage Racks
6. Final Verdict: Which Dumbbells Should You Buy?
Both Troy and York offer high-quality dumbells with distinct advantages. Here’s a quick recommendation:
-
Choose Troy Dumbbells if:
✅ You want long-lasting durability with urethane or rubber coatings.
✅ You need dumbbells for a commercial gym or intense training.
✅ You prefer ergonomic grips and premium build quality.
-
Choose York Dumbbells if:
✅ You’re looking for a budget-friendly option for home workouts.
✅ You prefer classic cast iron dumbbells for strength training.
✅ You want a cost-effective set of rubber hex dumbbells.
Final Thoughts
Troy Dumbbells vs. York Dumbbells – depending on your needs you can choose between Troy and York dumbbells, both brands deliver excellent performance. Troy dumbbells are the great option for long-term durability if you're spending money in a premium gym setup. York dumbbells are a great alternative if you're looking for an affordable and reliable option.
👉 Check out our full range of dumbbells for sale here:
🛒 Shop Troy Dumbbells
🛒 Shop York Dumbbells
Shop from Our Authorized Brands Today!
